Short Selling vs Long Investing: Two Sides of the Same Market

Every stock transaction requires a buyer and a seller. Similarly, the market functions with both optimists (long investors) and sceptics (short sellers). Understanding both perspectives doesn't just make you more informed — it makes you a better investor regardless of which side you're on.

The Fundamentals

Long Investing

Long investing is what most people think of when they hear "investing." You buy shares expecting them to increase in value over time.

Mechanics:

1. Buy shares at the current price
2. Hold them as the company (hopefully) grows
3. Sell later at a higher price
4. Collect dividends along the way

Risk profile:

• Maximum loss: 100% of your investment (stock goes to zero)
• Maximum gain: Unlimited (stock can rise indefinitely)
• Time is generally on your side — markets have historically trended upward

Short Selling

Short selling is the mirror image. You borrow shares and sell them, expecting to buy them back cheaper.

Mechanics:

1. Borrow shares from a broker or institutional lender
2. Sell them immediately at the current price
3. Wait for the price to (hopefully) drop
4. Buy them back at the lower price and return them
5. Pay borrowing fees for the duration

Risk profile:

• Maximum loss: Theoretically unlimited (stock can rise indefinitely)
• Maximum gain: Limited to 100% (stock goes to zero)
• Time works against you — borrowing costs accumulate daily

The Asymmetry That Changes Everything

The most important difference between long and short investing is the risk-reward asymmetry:

Long investor worst case: You buy a stock at $10. It goes to $0. You lose $10 per share. That's painful, but it's bounded.

Short seller worst case: You short a stock at $10. It goes to $50, then $100, then $200. Your loss per share keeps growing with no ceiling. This has destroyed hedge funds.

This asymmetry explains why short selling is primarily the domain of professional investors with sophisticated risk management systems. It's not that individual investors can't short sell — it's that the risk profile demands discipline that's difficult to maintain.

Why Short Sellers Matter to Long Investors

Even if you never short a single stock, understanding short selling makes you a better long investor. Here's why:

1. Short Sellers Are Free Research

When a stock has high short interest, professional investors with significant research resources are telling you they've found problems. You can agree or disagree, but ignoring that signal is leaving information on the table.

2. They Keep Markets Honest

Short sellers have exposed some of history's largest corporate frauds. Enron, Wirecard, and numerous Australian companies have been called out by short sellers before regulators acted. They provide an essential market discipline function.

3. They Create Buying Opportunities

When short sellers are wrong — and they often are — the subsequent short covering creates powerful rallies. If you've done your fundamental research and you're confident in a company, high short interest can actually work in your favour.

4. They Add Liquidity

Short selling increases trading volume and tightens bid-ask spreads, reducing costs for all market participants. Markets without short selling tend to be less efficient.

How Professionals Use Both Strategies

Long-Short Equity Funds

Many hedge funds run "long-short" strategies where they simultaneously hold long positions in stocks they like and short positions in stocks they don't. This approach:

• Reduces overall market exposure
• Generates returns from stock selection skill rather than market direction
• Provides some protection during market downturns

Pair Trading

A related strategy involves going long one stock and short a similar competitor. For example, going long BHP and short RIO if you believe BHP will outperform. The market direction becomes less important — what matters is the relative performance.

Hedging

Long investors sometimes use short positions to hedge specific risks in their portfolio. For example, a mining-heavy portfolio might short a mining ETF to reduce sector concentration risk.

The Australian Context

Australia has some unique features when it comes to short selling:

Transparency Advantage

ASIC requires daily reporting of short positions, making Australia one of the most transparent markets in the world for short selling data. This benefits long investors who can monitor bearish sentiment in real time.

Covered Short Selling Only

Australia generally prohibits naked short selling (selling shares you haven't borrowed). This means all short positions represent genuine borrowing arrangements, making the data more reliable.

The Franking Credit Factor

Australia's dividend imputation system creates an interesting dynamic. Long investors receive franking credits with dividends, but short sellers must pay the full dividend amount to the share lender. This makes shorting dividend-paying stocks more expensive and partially explains why high-yield ASX stocks tend to have lower short interest.

What Short Interest Tells Long Investors

Here's how to read short interest data as a long-term investor:

Low Short Interest (Under 2%)

• The market broadly agrees this is a decent company
• Doesn't mean it's a good buy — could already be fully valued
• Low risk of short-selling-driven volatility

Moderate Short Interest (2-5%)

• Normal market activity — nothing alarming
• Some institutional investors see risks worth betting against
• Worth a quick check on what bears are concerned about

High Short Interest (5-10%)

• Significant bearish sentiment — warrants investigation
• Ask yourself: do you understand the risks that shorts see?
• If you disagree with the thesis, your conviction needs to be strong

Very High Short Interest (10%+)

• Either the company has serious problems, or there's a contrarian opportunity
• Due diligence is non-negotiable at this level
• Be prepared for high volatility regardless of direction

Making Better Decisions

The best investors consider both the bull and bear cases for every position. Here's a framework:

1. Find the short thesis: What are bears saying about the stock? Check short interest data, read analyst reports, look for critical commentary.
2. Evaluate honestly: Are the concerns legitimate? Don't dismiss them just because you're bullish.
3. Quantify the risk: If the bears are right, how much could you lose? Is the position sized appropriately?
4. Monitor ongoing: Track changes in short interest over time. A rising short position after your purchase might mean new information has emerged.

Tools for Both Perspectives

Shorted.com.au provides the data infrastructure to understand the short side of the market:

• Daily short position updates for every ASX-listed stock
• Historical trend data to see how sentiment has evolved
• Industry-level analysis for sector-wide perspectives
• Weekly reports summarising the biggest moves in short interest

Whether you're a dedicated long investor, a short seller, or somewhere in between — understanding both sides of every trade makes you more informed and better prepared.

Explore ASX short selling data →

---

This content is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Both long investing and short selling carry risks. Always conduct thorough research and consider consulting a qualified financial advisor.